no, it's not to play outside scale volontary ,
it's only one notes ,
maybe guthrie makes ofen one shot to record ,
i think that because he never plays the same solos in lives and in cd,
u can believe me, this note isn't volontary ,
and i'm sur that guthrie could be alow with me ^^
You know why I can't take that seriously? Because you're French.
Only joking, but not really.
At Guthrie's level, mistakes are rarely ever made, so I think on a record, it would be safe to say that mistakes are never made.
ok i ve post for a joke ,
but when i heard again and again this note , there is a problem ,
i have been 8 years in an academy of classic music , and since i leave ,
i have learn blues rock jass fusion, and i m a futur professional guitarist ,
i don't care of this f*cking note , and i love guthrie, but i can't let u say that it's a chroma scale or other, because it's wrong ,
in Waves , there is no 'out' playing or other,
at the moment when there is this note , the style of guitar is bebop ,
and he does a fast A F#E before to do E F A C E , the arpeggio of F, so the tonality is F , this F# is wrong,
for the esthetics , and not only for the tonality ,
but i'm tired to discute about that ,
i stop argue , if u hear nothing wrong,
perfect
Really though in the end who really cares...if you're listenning to GG's stuff and trying to find errors then I feel sorry for you. When I listen to Guthrie's CD, I'm listening simply for pure enjoyment, and believe me I enjoy it, with or without these supposed mistakes.
Really though in the end who really cares...if you're listenning to GG's stuff and trying to find errors then I feel sorry for you. When I listen to Guthrie's CD, I'm listening simply for pure enjoyment, and believe me I enjoy it, with or without these supposed mistakes.
Most definatly agreed, his music is so beautiful, why look for mistakes?
Bonsoir Olivier. Comme vous êtes, ou, tu es, si tu préfères, enfin si vous préfèrez, je vais parler français, hein...
Et aussi, bravo pour votre oreille
salut, bon c'est pas la peine de me vous voyer , j'ai 19 ans donc je suis pas un monsieur ,
mais bravo pour le sens du respect dont tu fais preuve ,
moi je suis pas la pour descendre la music de guthrie,
je suis completement amoureux de son jeu ,
et waves est vraimant un titre fabuleux , mais une erreur est une erreur ,
en tout cas merci pour ton soutiens , je commencai a croire que seul moi entendait ca
i'm not looking for ,
when i listen music , if there is an error ,
i perceive that ,
...
If you are married and have children, then I honestly feel for them...and if you are aspiring to become a teacher, I suppose your ability to find errors without actually going out and looking for them may come in handy!
I think one of the main skills of a good improviser is to react fast on any note and then you can make it sound right. Guthrie actually talked about this in the interview that was posted on a website I don't remember. The author of that website promoted it here on this forum.
Anyway, Guthrie explained that you can make every note sound right with the notes that follow. So after a 'mistake', it all depends what you do next. And in that regard, there are no mistakes indeed, because you can correct them this way.
Last edited by RD on Sat Feb 10, 2007 6:41 pm; edited 1 time in total
Of course he makes mistakes, everyone does no matter how good they are, but they rarely leave them on a studio recording. There is definitely no mistake at the point to which you are referring. He has probably heard that passage of playing over 100 times during recording, playback and mixing at various stages and I'd say it's meant to sound exactly like it does!
As for breaking it down to exact notes theory wise you may as well forget that with GG's playing as he's pushing the listeners ear as far as possible with his stuff. If it sounds as though it's not 'in' to your ears then maybe try listening 'outside' like the rest of us are
Bonsoir Olivier. Comme vous êtes, ou, tu es, si tu préfères, enfin si vous préfèrez, je vais parler français, hein...
Et bien ce n'est pas par nationalisme, mais je suis d'accord Je n'avais jamais remarqué cette note, ce qui peut se comprendre puisque je n'aime pas spécialement ce titre, mais après l'avoir cherchée et réécoutée plusieurs fois, il y a effectivement quelque chose qui ne va pas, question esthétique. Je n'exlus pas l'hypothése de la fausse note (c'est pas correct comme terme, non ?), mais après tout, pourquoi Guthrie ne l'a-t-il pas fait exprès, sachant qu'elle passerai inaperçue pour pas mal de monde, apparement ? (moi y compris )
Sinon, dans le post précédant le vôtre, l'internaute dit que à ce niveau, les guitaristes ne font presque plus d'erreurs... J'ai pourtant, dans le dvd Crossroad de Eric Clapton, Steve Vai qui joue un morceau, dans lequel il fait plusieurs erreurs de ce style. Steve Vai que je n'apprecis guére d'ailleur, que par son côté technique...
Voilà mon petit coup de gueule, au plaisir de vous recontrer un jour, puisque vous allez devenir professionel ? J'aimerai voir percer un guitariste de "blues rock jazz fusion", comme vous l'avez dit, étant fan et guitariste de "jazz rock fusion progressif", comme je le dis.
Bien amicalement.
PS: Excusez moi pour mon français, je le suis... et je n'ai que 15 ans
Et aussi, bravo pour votre oreille
Please lose the large image as it knocks the page out of whack _________________ Fabulous powers were revealed to me the day I held my magic Suhr(d) aloft and said "by the power of great scale!"
Posted: Sun Feb 11, 2007 6:31 pm Post subject: whatever he likes
when you are composing something you can do whatever it comes across your mind, why do you worry about a single note that was placed anywhere on the fretboard, he is more than qualified to do this like anybody else. _________________ www.soundclick.com my nickname Meliton
some friend guitarists and pianists PROFESSIONAL have heard that
and there are agree with me ,
sorry if i more believe some professional guys and my ears more that ure sayin'
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in to check your private messages
Log in
,
,
)
)
